Bethmayhem Bakery, founded by Beth Turner, joined East Town’s Business Membership program in January 2025 and is making their debut as a new Cathedral Square Market vendor this year. Get to know Bethmayhem and where you can find their must-try treats this season.
About Bethmayhem Bakery
“Every bite reflects love, care, and attention to detail, honoring tradition while embracing creativity. With options like gluten-free, vegan, and classic recipes, it’s more than baking—it’s an experience.”
– Bethany Turner, Owner and Sweets Dealer of Bethmayhem LLC
Bethmayhem’s menu features an array of cookies and cakes, complemented by a range of gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan options. Have you ever treated yourself to a lavender Earl Grey scone with a lemon glaze? Each month, they features a themed dessert box available for purchase, usually coinciding with holidays.
Bethmayhem also offers specialized dessert catering services for small-scale events, including weddings, birthday parties, corporate functions, bachelorette parties and book clubs. Plus, their DIY classes are tailored to suit all ages, covering topics such as bread-making, cookie and cupcake decoration, STEM baking, and more.
March 17th, 2025 marked 3 years in business!
Locations
Serving Milwaukee, Ozaukee and Washington Counties
Shipping options also available
Contact
Meet Bethany at an upcoming event or email Bethmayhem2500@gmail.com.
Upcoming Events
March 15
Maple Sugarin’ Festival
12–4 pm at Riveredge Nature Center (Saukville)
March 22/April 12
Saukville Winter Market
10 am–2 pm at American Legion (Saukville)
March 29
Phenomenal Women Marketplace
1–6 pm at American Black Holocaust Museum (Milwaukee)
April 27
Walker’s Point Makers Market
12–4 pm at Broken Bat Brewing Co (Milwaukee)
May 10
Hosting: Cupcake Decorating
2–4 pm at Sugar Maple
Q&A
What goals does your business have for the coming years?
“Our key goals for the next couple years involve expanding our team to improve our customer experience and obtain funding for a dessert cart.”
– Bethany Turner, Owner and Sweets Dealer of Bethmayhem LLC
Interested in Becoming an East Town Association Member?
Unlock promotion opportunities, connect with other local businesses and invest in the future of our community through the East Town Association Membership Program. Explore benefits and pricing here.